A few weeks ago I tweeted grouchily that this government appears to me to have an absolute contempt for the law and the truth. Let me explain.
1. Torture
At the time, I was thinking about David Miliband‘s shameless (and on-going) attempt to prevent public access to information on the UK’s complicity in torture. Incidentally, one reason for Mr Miliband’s desperation and fury could be that members and former members of this government might be vulnerable to criminal charges [1,2,3].
(If you’re thinking that if torture were to save lives, it might be okay, may I – before I say “torture is simply wrong” – refer you to How To Break A Terrorist. And then may I point out the results of a recent high-profile torture interrogation? I’m referring to the Iraq War, one of whose principal justifications was derived from information from the torture of Ibn al Sheikh al-Libi. Sadly, we can’t ask for clarification, because he later died in prison.
Torture is a very bad way of getting good information.
It’s also just wrong.)
2. Health
I’m writing this blog post today because I think Alan Johnson has frankly demonstrated that he is unsuited to a post in government and should resign. In case you haven’t read so much as a lolly stick for the last few days…
David Nutt was head of the government’s Advisory Council on the Misuse of Drugs. He believes that government drugs policy should be built on science. He said so. He has been sacked. The other members of the council are appalled and may resign in sympathy. The rest of the scientific community is in uproar.
Alan Johnson’s response? He’s putting the ACMD to fire and sword. Rather than hear the truth on a difficult issue, he is actively assailing the mechanism by which it can be delivered to him. That is not responsible government. It does not approach the kind of wisdom and integrity I want to see in someone who aspires to high office.
It is pathetic.
3. Environment
Yes, yes, I know. Some of you are convinced that global climate change is a big lie. That is absolutely beside the point. The government’s policy is that climate change is real. And yet it is also quietly screwing up treaties which are needed to prevent it.
4. War
Remember the Dodgy Dossier? The 45 minute claim? Remember how we went to war to get Saddam’s weapons of mass destruction? So where are they? Fallen down the crack in some vast secret sofa in the desert?
5. Civil Liberties.
Remember Jack Straw’s letter on civil liberties? I took issue with it at the time. It’s no less nonsensical to me now. This government has eroded and diminished our civil liberties while trumpeting its commitment to them.
This stuff goes on and on. Every day brings some new instance of it.
That was what I meant when I said this government seemed to be demonstrating contempt for the law and the truth.
I’m not saying the next one will be better. I sincerely doubt that it will be. I voted for this government, albeit not recently.
And yet now I feel increasingly that it is a disgrace.
I hope that’s clear.