Thinking With My Hands

23/03/09

A lonely figure, coat flapping, scribbling frantically in a notebook on a precipitous clifftop, ignoring the rain and the wind, possessed and animated by the creative spirit

Or on the bus, clamped into the corner seat and muttering like a madman, poetry and prose spilling out into the page

Or in the middle of the night, leaping from the bed to scribe in the gloaming or the gloom: I must just get this down

Iconic writer behaviour – and it does happen. In fact, I think it counts as one of the subsidiary (but vital) writing skills to know when you actually need to do it and when it’s just a way of annoying your family and escaping the washing up. Living with a writer isn’t always easy; you owe it to those around you to learn when to use your creative license to behave like a lunatic, and when to let it go.

That’s by the by. The point is: the end product of all these moments is a pile of notebooks, and if you’re like me, they’re just the beginning of the problem… because there are times when you don’t have a notebook. Half of my writing has always been done on the back of till receipts, napkins, paper place-mats and utility bills. It has been written in pencil, pen, crayon, and even eyeliner. It has been written on ferries, at balls, in pubs, on planes, at clubs, on my honeymoon (at Clare’s urging and with her enthusiastic connivance) and yes, in the middle of the night.

I also have a habit of writing on my left arm – note carefully, not just the back of my hand, but all the way around the wrist and up until about two inches from the elbow. The benefit of this last method is that it has to be transcribed as soon as you get the chance or it fades, so it goes onto the computer directly. The other stuff… piles up.

All of which leaves a great pile of stuff, both handwritten and digital, waiting for review.

And beyond the occasional flashes of inspiration, there’s also the moment when I deliberately discard the computer and use a pen. My handwriting is pretty awful, so I do it as little as I can, but there’s a different atmosphere and mood to scribbling with a pen or even a pencil on blank paper compared with working on a keyboard. I read somewhere that you actually use different bits of your brain, and use them to make different brainwaves.

So when I need to plot the big picture, for example, or when I want to interrogate myself about something which isn’t necessarily working, I end up using pen and paper to do it. That goes into the notebook, too.

Because there’s freewheeling implied in the process, the end result usually includes at least one idea for a completely different story, and a lot of doodling.

Incidentally, doodling is par for the course. I saw some of Pushkin’s manuscripts in a museum in Russia a while ago, and around the edges were drawn – exquisitely, I might add – erotic sketches of women playing billiards in the nude and randy satyrs chasing nymphs.

The question is, what then?

Well, okay. For some stuff it’s easy. If I’ve just written a great swathe of text about Gonzo and Jim Hepsobah, that gets typed up and re-written and it goes into the book. Or doesn’t. It gets dealt with. And then there’s the plotting scribbles, the great enthusiastic arrows and detailed flow-charts and the rest. Most of those I absorb or discard and never need to see again. They were a physical thought process, not a reminder or a note. They were about coming to the conclusion, not about noting anything for future reference. I was thinking with my hands. 

But sprinkled through them is gold-dust. Tiny character notes; wayward notions about what might have worked if I hadn’t already done x, and then it turns out that x has to be cut for another reason and lo and behold I need that other plan. And ideas, my God. Treasure trove ideas for other things. Stories about Marlon Agonistes, the main character in my story for The Verb a few weeks ago – I must see about getting that into something or putting it online here. My next novel, or the one after that. The genesis of the piece I’m praying will go into Granta later this year.

So what do you do with your notebooks?

Keep them for ever. Put them in a pile. They are your bank account, to draw on at need. Embrace the fact that you are not the kind of person who can catalogue them and file the bits of random paper which say things like:

Before I tell you about Royden, I should probably mention that I murdered him. 

Or:

Crazy guy, crimson shirt => => terribly afraid of nudity. Why? Evil tattoo? Disease/disfigurement?

You may or may not remember why that was important. It may mean nothing to you today. But it might trip you off tomorrow, set you going down some strange track which resembles or doesn’t remotely touch on the thing you were originally thinking about.

Going through them looking for something in particular is painfully frustrating, but leafing through the weird outpourings of your own brain will always give you something. Don’t fight it. Follow it. The worst that happens is that you burn an hour daydreaming about wonderful notions which don’t deal with whatever you wanted to work on. That’s part of your job. And it may unlock something in your head you didn’t know needed it.

Notebooks are your mind’s footprints. They’re your holiday album from writer-world.

Keep ‘em. And cherish the fact that they’re disorganised and nutso and you can’t find what you’re looking for. If you could, you’d be a different person.

8 Comments to “Thinking With My Hands”

  • Eeoor said on March 23rd, 2009:

    Haha! My plea to the world for a way to organise my notebooks is answered!

    Not in the way I expected, but in a way that makes me feel much better about the piles of well, crap, let’s be honest, that I leave all over the place.

    Everyone always tells you to keep notebooks, and eventually it does become second nature. I just never thought I’d figured out what came next. I’m glad that I’m not the only one whose notebooks make little sense and who reads them as an escape from what they’re “meant” to be doing!

  • Nick Harkaway said on March 23rd, 2009:

    Seriously – it’s not an escape. It’s the real deal. It’s just oblique. I find, at least, that tackling story problems head on doesn’t always work, but getting your brain into the right space and freewheeling can be very helpful. Mind you, so can cooking or painting the wall.

  • Matt Keefe said on March 23rd, 2009:

    Have you noticed how the image of the writer and his notebook – perhaps more so than ever now that computers are the norm – is actually being used to sell notebooks? Waterstones have started selling moleskine notebooks advertised as ‘the notebook of Ernest Hemingway’ at a tenner a pop.

    I’m fortunate enough to have acquired the habit of typing up my notes within about a day or so of writing them, so I’ve no real problem with notebooks mounting up. I’m also perfectly happy taking notes on computer (where I have one to hand) – I don’t find it more restrictive or less conducive to wild flights of fancy as some seem to. Funnily enough, when the notes are meandering and disorderly, I often don’t have a useful title for the file and often, I’m ashamed to admit, resort to a random bash of the keyboard to provide a filename, making the computer notes just as difficult to look through as any old notebook. Silly me.

    I had a piece of flash fiction (hate that term) published which I’d originally written in full in a notebook. I put both versions (the handwritten, and the final version) online for comparison, making much the same point about the usefulness of notebooks at the same time, of course: http://thestarchamber.mattkeefe.com/published-a-very-short-story

    Apparently doodling is the sign of an alert mind. I don’t know if this fact might have a bearing on the relative desirability of using pen and paper, compared to a computer, in certain situations: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/7912671.stm

  • Nick Harkaway said on March 23rd, 2009:

    *grin*

    I had noticed that about the way they now market notebooks. I almost mentioned it. “doff o’ the cap*

    Nice BBC link – thanks.

  • Matt Keefe said on March 23rd, 2009:

    I’ll confess I nearly fell for it. I considered buying one of those pocket books – doubtless some of the association with genius appealed, but more sensibly the elasticated bands in the covers and the pocket for loose papers sound genuinely useful (at least, I told myself they did) – but then I just asked myself, if I’d actually forked out a tenner on a single measly notepad would I even want to besmirch it with my vagrant script?

    For that kind of money, and with that kind of prestige attached, I’d be wanting to write the opening bars of symphonies in it, or sit with it in Parisian cafés sketching the beautiful waitresses. Since I can neither write music nor draw (nor easily reach Parisian cafés of a morning) I decide the 79p WHSmiths ones remained the best bet. Will it hold me back? I’ll simply never know.

  • Nick Harkaway said on December 6th, 2009:

    For what it’s worth, here we are on Dec 6th 09 and I’m reading those two lines – Royden and the guy in the crimson shirt – and loving them both. I made them up as examples, but they do have something.

    Later.

    Must finish new novel.

    Yes.

    Must not write about scar-boy.

    Not today.

  • Rebecca said on December 7th, 2009:

    Funny you mentioned the Moleskine notebooks… I thought just the same when I was reading your post (great by the way, loved it!). I am guilty as charged for buying them religiously.

    Before I was given my first Moleskine, I used to write in all sorts of notebooks, really whatever I liked best at the time. It sounds really corny but it never felt “right”. I’d never heard of Moleskine notebooks before but as soon as I started to write in it, I knew I’d arrived.

    Personally, I am more than happy to fork out the tenner for these notebooks (I’m very picky tho — A6 blank hardcover only with a cheap black BIC pen). The reason being that for me they are the paper equivalent of the “one” who passed you by and you knew in an instant that you never wanted to be with anyone else ever again.

    My 2p :)

  • Gregg Fraley said on December 7th, 2009:

    Its a fact that highly creative people, in the arts and sciences, use notebooks. It’s the “One Thing” a person can do to amp up their effectiveness. Essentially it’s a system for: noticing, recording, reviewing, and taking action on various ideas.

    I think you are spot on when it comes to the “oblique” bit. Great ideas often come to us through seemingly random associations; best to notice them and write them down. Your brain will help you make connections over time.

    I posted a piece on this as well, having to do with examples of women “notebookers,” including Beatrix Potter.

    See: http://www.greggfraley.com/blog/?p=290 if interested.

    Regards,
    Gregg Fraley
    author of Jack’s Notebook

Add your comment: